Trustwave SpiderLabs Uncovers Ov3r_Stealer Malware Spread via Phishing and Facebook Advertising. Learn More

Trustwave SpiderLabs Uncovers Ov3r_Stealer Malware Spread via Phishing and Facebook Advertising. Learn More

Services
Capture
Managed Detection & Response

Eliminate active threats with 24/7 threat detection, investigation, and response.

twi-managed-portal-color
Co-Managed SOC (SIEM)

Maximize your SIEM investment, stop alert fatigue, and enhance your team with hybrid security operations support.

twi-briefcase-color-svg
Advisory & Diagnostics

Advance your cybersecurity program and get expert guidance where you need it most.

tw-laptop-data
Penetration Testing

Test your physical locations and IT infrastructure to shore up weaknesses before exploitation.

twi-database-color-svg
Database Security

Prevent unauthorized access and exceed compliance requirements.

twi-email-color-svg
Email Security

Stop email threats others miss and secure your organization against the #1 ransomware attack vector.

tw-officer
Digital Forensics & Incident Response

Prepare for the inevitable with 24/7 global breach response in-region and available on-site.

tw-network
Firewall & Technology Management

Mitigate risk of a cyberattack with 24/7 incident and health monitoring and the latest threat intelligence.

Solutions
BY TOPIC
Microsoft Exchange Server Attacks
Stay protected against emerging threats
Rapidly Secure New Environments
Security for rapid response situations
Securing the Cloud
Safely navigate and stay protected
Securing the IoT Landscape
Test, monitor and secure network objects
Why Trustwave
About Us
Awards and Accolades
Trustwave SpiderLabs Team
Trustwave Fusion Security Operations Platform
Trustwave Security Colony
Partners
Technology Alliance Partners
Key alliances who align and support our ecosystem of security offerings
Trustwave PartnerOne Program
Join forces with Trustwave to protect against the most advance cybersecurity threats
SpiderLabs Blog

ModSecurity User Survey Results Released

As a result of the acquisition of Breach Security (and thus ModSecurity) by Trustwave, we thought that it was a good time to run another User Survey to get a better understanding of how the community is using ModSecurity and, most importantly, how we can make it better. We ran a survey during the month of September 2010. Thanks to everyone who took the time to respond as it will help to steer the development of ModSecurity.

We plan to run these official user surveys once a year, however don't forget that you can always voice your concerns and bring up issues on the ModSecurity mail-list and also in the Jira ticketing system. Speaking of Jira, I wanted to remind everyone that you can always log into Jira to see the latest ticket/roadmap items. And taking this one step further, you can actually VOTE on an item which will help us to prioritize which issues get fixed first and also which feature requests will make it into different versions.

ModSecurity User Survey 2010 Results

You can review the complete stats here. For this blog post, however, I wanted to highlight the most interesting questions/results and provide a bit of commentary.

12084_d891e3c4-d09b-402d-8bcd-465e3179fa67
Analysis:

As you can see, ModSecurity is being used widely across vertical markets. It is interesting to see that the top current users are now Consultants. I attribute this mostly to the emerging importance of using ModSecurity as a Virtual Patching tool to mitigate identified vulnerabilities.

10695_94e4cc1d-5bd2-432c-a090-ae6f312dbe14

Analysis:

As mentioned in the previous section, virtual patching is probably the most popular use-case scenario for initially deploying ModSecurity (or any WAF for that matter). Some other interesting benefits are blocking technical/sensitive data leakages and also increased HTTP transactional logging. Speaking of the latter, I can attest to the effectiveness of promoting ModSecurity's Audit Engine capabilities to help with operational trouble-shooting. This is how I initially pitched deploying ModSecurity to the web server admins back in the day. By showing them complete HTTP transactions, they were able to more quickly fix issues.

 

9460_5aa657cb-df8d-451f-9ef1-fd76cf435ec7

Analysis:

I am hoping that the @modsecurity Twitter account will pick up some more followers. :)

 

7763_07b9e4c4-97eb-4a03-a291-2136d1480d0d

Analysis:

The responses to this question were pretty much as expected. There any different ways to try and address web application security issues and organizations should use them all. The combination of conducting static/dynamic web application testing and then implementing custom virtual patches is gaining momentum as there seem to be more and more scenarios where identified vulns can't be fixed in the code at all or it will take a significant period of time. In the former case, a virtual patch is about the only option, and in the latter case, a virtual patch can at least provide some level of mitigation until the source code level fix is implemented.

 

7614_00a6f7c5-cc41-4a38-ba80-ad351515ac8e

Analysis:

There are two main rationales for wanting custom rule sets built for a specific piece of software -

  1. To reduce false positives
  2. To reduce false negatives

These are constant battles with "generic" signatures as they do not know of exact attack vector locations. Application rule set packages will need to either have a listing of known vuln signatures or a positive security profile created. In either case, it will require on-going monitoring of updates to public software to identify new vulns and also create new positive security profiles when new functionality is added. Trustwave SpiderLabs is researching the feasibility of creating a real-time rules feed for newly released webappsec vulns in public software. We are are also looking at adding in learning capabilities to ModSecurity by using new Lua scripts for profiling web apps.

9383_571a1e33-464a-4739-b0cf-d9856d48d9e9

Analysis:

The good news is that we are working on plans to implement just about all of these features/capabilities into ModSecurity :) Keep an eye out for future updates.

8439_2917eb81-7733-43c3-b0ec-316461216748

Analysis:

As you can see, there is a pretty wide range of the number of sites being protected. Many users use ModSecurity just to protect one local web site while there are others who use ModSecurity to protect entire server farms consisting of hundreds of systems. That is the beauty of the embedded deployment model - scale.

 

9569_60d38a05-2ec9-455b-bde3-2119438f5d88

Analysis:

I believe that there is a misconception that ModSecurity can only be used in an open-source/LAMP type of deployment. As evidenced by the responses to this question, ModSecurity is platform/application language agnostic. It will protect any type of web application including commercial/custom coded applications that are used for ecommerce, banking, etc...

 

11671_c4eca5fb-4acf-4be7-84c7-ea6d75b11cc4

Analysis:

This question also proves the point raised in the previous section and that is that if you have an Apache reverse proxy with ModSecurity, you can front-end any back-end web applications with WAF technology. I know of many users who use this setup to protect different back-end apps including IIS/ASP.Net types of technology.

 

8283_2071c8e9-57f9-4187-8ace-2286abf29425

Analysis:

Woohoo! I am glad to see that the vast majority of users are using the newest ModSecurity versions. The main hurdle to upgrading is if the currently deployed Apache version is the 1.3 branch then they can't use the newer code.

 

8586_305ca56f-08d4-4b95-8f2a-d86dcef388cc

Analysis:

Pretty evenly split between embedded mode vs. proxy mode.

 

BSL_12210_df7388d5-3bd2-494f-b897-434f7dca5971

Analysis:

Ideally, all users would be using the OWASP CRS (with local exceptions) along with their own custom rules for identified virtual patches. I would venture to guess that the main reason why the people who are *only* using custom rules is that they ran into false positive issues with the CRS. Making exceptions easier is a major goal of future ModSecurity/CRS releases.

8872_3ea22aab-743b-4660-9bd5-7240356df566

Analysis:

The total number of rules running may become important if you start to experience performance issues such as higher latency of transactions or spikes in CPU/RAM. The total number of rules isn't usually the biggest concern but rather if you have any specific rules that are not performing well.

 

9631_6442354d-9590-4ca4-861f-31e0422b7843

Analysis:

This is an interesting question when you consider how much time the average user has to review ModSecurity alerts/audit log data. Keep in mind that this number is usually impacted by both untuned rules and by the amount of attack traffic you receive. Even if you tune your rules, however, you may still get a rather large number of events if your site is actively being probed/attacked. If you want high fidelity alerts (meaning ones in which you may need to take some form of incident response action upon) then you will have to spend a bit of time up front to tune your rules.

 

8489_2bf9f8ba-eab5-4ad9-a87c-3ebec4a7afb8

Analysis:

Managing ModSecurity audit events is a critical issue from a situational awareness perspective. The two best options currently are:

  1. Christian Bockermann's AuditConsole - it has really taken the concept created by the original ModSecurity community console and taken it to new heights. It is highly recommended as it was built from the ground up to handle ModSecurity audit log data.
  2. SIEM Integration - it is rather easy to reconfigure your Apache host to send its error_log data (which will include the short ModSecurity message) onto a remote SIEM host via syslog. Your mileage will vary though as to how well the SIEM is able to parse, search and report on ModSecurity messages.

8910_40ed04ac-a9e4-4bd8-a8ed-a64d97750afa

Analysis:

This task is certainly tricky... It is often tough for the average user to confirm if a ModSecurity event is accurate or may need some level of tuning to handle authorized functionality. When I work with commercial customers who are implementing WAFs, I often refer them to the excellent OWASP Best Practices: Use of Web Application Firewall document. Specifically, organizations should make sure that they have the proper staff to administer the WAF. In this case, we are referring to the WAF Application Manager role:

8.3.2 WAF application manager (per application)

 

Tasks:

  • Implementation and maintainance of the WAF configuration specific to the application
  • Monitoring and analysis of the log files (at least on the second level)
  • Contact for error messages, in particular false positives analysis in collaboration with the application manager
  • Close cooperation with the WAF application managers and platform managers
  • Test of WAF functionalities for the application, especially when deploying new versions of the application

 

Knowledge:

  • In-depth knowledge of the WAF configuration in relation to application-specific security mechanism
  • Very good knowledge of the behaviour of the application, in particular input, output, uploads, downloads, character sets, etc.

 

11223_af20229e-ffe0-4acd-af65-98509456f168

Analysis:

In general, a false positive rate of >10% isn't bad. The main issue is when you fact in any blocking methods being used. If a rule is incorrectly disrupting non-malicious user activities then it can become a big problem. Interestingly, anyone who actually answered this question is more then likely in a smaller subset of ModSecurity users who actually do spend time reviewing their logs! People who don't review their logs can't answer this question.

 

BSL_11327_b3500ccb-fdb7-40e4-bbe6-06f7ff65171c

Analysis:

The people who answered the they are in DetectionOnly mode more than likely don't have enough time to properly tune their rules to their application environment which means they have a higher degree of false positives. The users who answered that they are in a Blocking mode have been able to tune and therefore have a higher comfort level with taking action.

 

BSL_10837_9c2862c9-8c7d-4013-9cc8-4f639dcf2b57

Analysis:

Let me ask a question - an attacker figures out some sort of evasion for your current signatures, how are you ever going to know what happened? Or look at it from this perspective - say that you identify someone attacking your site and then you initiate incident response and the CISO asks you to provide logs of *everything* that user did. Will you be able to do this? Unfortunately, most users run ModSecurity in an "Alert-centric" mode in which audit logs are only created when rules match. This is a shame as it is missing one of its greatest strengths - HTTP Auditing. If you want to do session reconstruction, you MUST audit log all transactions. Now, this being said, you can still choose to not log requests for static content (such as images, etc...) and this will drastically cut down on the number of transactions being logged.

BSL_10766_986cedff-eab4-4813-9869-e25021195cba

Analysis:

While there are use-cases for utilizing different disruptive actions, I am becoming more and more of a fan simply emulating how the application responds currently to similar threats. Does it do a redirect back to the homepage or throw a 403 alerts? Whatever it is, simply mimic that response so that it is not as easy for an advanced attacker to enumerate that fact that you are running a WAF.

 

9008_45d013f3-778c-4ad2-aaea-2530888f2379

Analysis:

Hopefully the new "Advanced Topic of the Week" blogpost series is helping to shed some light on these features and capabilities.

 

 

12629_f1a757e8-1939-4a70-beed-bf2ed928324c

Analysis:

As I mentioned in the previous section, we are trying to provide more data about how to actually use these advanced ModSecurity features.

Latest SpiderLabs Blogs

Hunting For Integer Overflows In Web Servers

Allow me to set the scene and start proceedings off with a definition of an integer overflow, according to Wikipedia:

Read More

Welcome to Adventures in Cybersecurity: The Defender Series

I’m happy to say I’m done chasing Microsoft certifications (AZ104/AZ500/SC100), and as a result, I’ve had the time to put some effort into a blog series that hopefully will entertain and inform you...

Read More

Trustwave SpiderLabs: Insights and Solutions to Defend Educational Institutions Against Cyber Threats

Security teams responsible for defending educational institutions at higher education and primary school levels often find themselves facing harsh lessons from threat actors who exploit the numerous...

Read More